
News| 5.9.2024
An Answer to the Shortage of Space in Metropolitan Areas
Pioneering work. The two-story logistics property Mach 2 in Hamburg received much praise and a flagship award. However, before the praise and recognition came, developer Four Parx faced significant challenges. Managers Francisco J. Bähr and Oliver Schmitt discuss their experiences and future plans.
Immobilien Zeitung: Mr. Schmitt, after Mach 2 in Hamburg—what is your next flagship project?
Oliver Schmitt: When realizing a project like Mach 2, which involved a lot of pioneering work due to the lack of previous experience, many factors must align. It requires careful pre-development, but also time. We are currently working on a location that we believe holds great potential. However, it’s not about simply executing unique real estate projects; we aim to develop solutions that meet the needs of both users and municipalities. Mach 2 addressed the space shortage in metropolitan areas with high, ongoing demand.
IZ: Mach 2 received a lot of praise—even from competitors. Does that inspire you?
Francisco J. Bähr: Yes, it does. We are proud that the project is being positively received. Those of us at Four Parx who are dedicated to the design and development of innovative logistics properties are constantly seeking visionary solutions to industry challenges, be it new mobility solutions, alternative energy supplies, or compact space planning. When projects like this succeed despite numerous challenges—such as difficult soil conditions during the development of Mach 2—we can be genuinely pleased.
IZ: However, there was some criticism. Some said, “Mach 2 is way too big, too bulky, and most users in Germany don’t need something like this.” How do you respond to that?
Bähr: It’s not about creating a real estate concept that meets the needs of all users in the market. In my view, that’s impossible and not effective. That’s why Four Parx has a diverse portfolio tailored to individual user requirements. Many users in Germany may not need a property like Mach 2. However, for users looking for rental space in costly, limited-space locations like metropolitan areas, multi-story properties will eventually become unavoidable. That’s precisely why we developed Mach 2. The fact that it was fully leased before completion shows we made the right call.
IZ: Implementing the project faced issues with soil, water, and unexploded ordnance. Was Mach 2 still profitable for Four Parx despite these costly obstacles and delays?
Schmitt: True, due to Hamburg’s history of heavy bombing in WWII, extensive unexploded ordnance inspections were necessary. Until the findings were safely assessed and removed, the entire area had to be closed off. Additionally, the unique soil characteristics near Hamburg harbor required special solutions and foundations. These factors brought additional costs, but most were budgeted. In the end, Mach 2 was still a financial success for Four Parx.
IZ: Will you keep the property or is a sale planned?
Schmitt: As a developer and manager, we also hold properties. However, we typically plan to sell the projects we develop. Mach 2 was fully transferred to the fund of our project partner, the asset manager AEW, after completion.
IZ: How did you finance it? Did the banks participate?
Schmitt: Our partner played a crucial role in financing as well. The project was 100% funded through an AEW fund.
IZ: The final costs were 215 million euros. Would you undertake the project again?
Bähr: Given that the value of Mach 2 after completion and leasing exceeded the costs, we would undertake the project again anytime. Additionally, with the experience gained from this pilot project, we could build such a property more affordably today. However, we would handle some aspects differently, such as fire protection. During Mach 2's construction, we had to meet many requirements that, in hindsight, were unnecessary. Now, with our prototype, we can show which measures are truly effective. It’s worth remembering that none of the participants had experience building such a property at the time.
IZ: Will there be a follow-up project in Germany?
Bähr: As far as I know, similar projects are already being built. We also have other two-story properties in planning, and we would be delighted to bring one of these projects to life soon.
IZ: In 2018, you announced at Expo Real that you planned to build three such properties. What happened to the projects in the Rhine-Main area?
Bähr: Six years after the announcement, both construction plans have not been realized for various reasons. However, given the great success in Hamburg, we are now planning to develop new properties similar to Mach 2 on suitable sites.
IZ: And where might that be?
Bähr: It’s too early to say anything specific.
IZ: Despite the praise, few other developers have ventured into a similar project. Why not? The blueprint is there.
Schmitt: It’s true that Mach 2 created the template for a two-story logistics and commercial property. However, the challenges of such a project, with high risks and complex permitting processes, are still significant and deter many. Implementing a project like Mach 2 requires considerable experience, reserves, and a willingness to take risks.
IZ: In other countries, multi-story buildings are almost standard. What’s different in Germany compared to France or the UK?
Bähr: Fundamentally, there are hardly any differences between Germany and other countries. We simply have a few additional requirements here that drive up costs. In times of crisis, like falling returns, these added costs can increase risk. And the current market is still marked by uncertainty, which curbs the willingness of many developers.
IZ: Given the requirements for reducing land consumption, multi-story buildings will eventually become almost unavoidable, right?
Schmitt: Correct. The German government’s plan to reduce green space consumption by 2030 and achieve zero by 2050 demands innovative solutions to continue meeting the need for space. But even with hybrid concepts that combine various asset classes, space will eventually run out. If the goal is to minimize land use permanently, multi-story construction will become increasingly necessary in sustainable logistics and commercial buildings.
IZ: How have rents at Mach 2 evolved? What is charged for the lower and upper floors?
Schmitt: Rents have risen sharply in all metropolitan areas in recent years, including Hamburg at Mach 2. However, we do not differentiate between the floors.
IZ: How many true multi-story logistics properties do you think Germany will have by 2030?
Bähr: Unfortunately, too few. Optimistically, there may be five such properties. This requires a faster market recovery and that multi-story developments prove profitable. We at Four Parx would like to stick to our plan and add more properties modeled after Mach 2, possibly one or two in the Rhine-Main area and one in Bavaria.
IZ: Thank you for the interview.
The interview was conducted by Peter Dietz.